ksilver (silver05) wrote in ask_me_anything,

Slave rebellion

In which I sum up 115 pages of reading in two paragraphsCollapse )

So in reading about this failed insurrection, especially its aftermath, I found myself thinking about it from both perspectives. I think that if violent armed invaders were going to march on a major city, I would want them captured and those involved punished as well. So on that point, I think the white Virginians were right. And yet the black rebels were right, too -- the system was extremely unfair (to put it mildly) and they have an right, an unalienable right if you will, to call for better treatment.

I really wish that we had had an opportunity to discuss the book in class, but we didn't. What do you guys think? Who was right? Is there one right side?

(oh my gosh I hate analyzing history this way -- "should haves" but I want to discuss this with somebody)
  • Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded